Let’s take a look at The Mill River Recluse: A Novel by Darcie Chan from a Reader’s Perspective.
This post contains spoilers.
Darcie Chan’s The Mill River Recluse: A Novel*
(*Amazon Affiliate link)
The Mill River Recluse, by Darcie Chan, is next up on our 100 Bestsellers List reading challenge.
Mary McAllister has lived alone for sixty years, rarely leaving her house or meeting with anyone other than her only friend, the parish priest. From her house overlooking the sleepy Vermont town of Mill River, she pretends to herself that she is a member of the community. But she’s not, and most of the residents of Mill River think of her as rather peculiar, if they think of her at all. Everyone in this story has a secret to keep, some benign, some not so benign. In the end, a feeling of real community is kindled once all the secrets are revealed.
So far, all the books we’ve read have been intense, evoking strong emotions from the reader – either you really liked or really disliked the book. The Mill River Recluse is the first book in this challenge that left me feeling rather disappointed. Don’t get me wrong! It is a nice read and leaves you feeling a little warm and fuzzy inside. The small amount of violence is really rather subdued if you compare it to our previous book, The Last Child by John Hart. I was left feeling like it could have been much more, though, than just a nice read.
Amazon lists The Mill River Recluse as a psychological thriller. As such, it leaves a lot to be desired. It seemed more like your run-of-the-mill episode of a seventies detective series, not much in the way of character development for the bad guy (so much for “psychological”) and certainly not much of a “thriller” in his actions. He comes across more a bumbling fool than a terror.
By now you might be asking yourself why this book is on the 100 Books List. I know I was. So I pulled out my notes from The Bestseller Code and checked what the computer algorithm looks for when choosing a likely bestseller.
- 3 or 4 central themes, with the most frequently occurring and important theme involving human closeness, followed by home, work, kids in school, and modern technologies. The Mill River Recluse is 100% about human closeness, both at home and at work, and also include interaction with kids. Checkmark on this one!
- Plot lines with a regular beating rhythm. The chapters in The Mill River Recluse alternate between the 1940s and present day, building the backstory of Mary while at the same time introducing us to those who live in present day Mill River. Checkmark this one!
- Style. The author should have an understanding of everyday language, i.e. working experience in journalism or similar field. Darcie Chan worked in the legal field before becoming a successful author. Checkmark this one!
So maybe the computer did pick a winner. The fact that this book was on the New York Times bestseller list for several months backs up the computer’s choice. Just because I think this book doesn’t have the literary or emotional “heft” it should have to belong on the 100 Books List is the fault of my own expectations. Obviously, a heart-warming, feel-good book can be a bestseller if it is well written. After all, bestsellers aren’t all thriller / mysteries or literary adventures.
What did you think of The Mill River Recluse Child? We’d love to hear your thoughts!
- The Mill River Recluse landing page
- Book-beginnings, a discussion of the first line of the novel
- Roberta’s review from a writer’s perspective
After you finish the book, you might want to drop by to take our survey.
You can also join us on social media:
- The Bestseller Code 100 Pinterest Page
- Twitter: #BestsellerCode100
- Facebook: Bestseller Code 100 Reading Group
- The full list is now posted on GoodReads
Do you have suggestions for ways to improve this reading challenge? We’d love to hear them.
What are we reading next?
If you ever have questions about what we are reading next or when we’re starting the next discussion, check the 100 Book List tab in the navigation bar at the top of the blog.
The next book is number 94 on the list, The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets’ Nest by Stieg Larsson (Originally published in 2007) – Discussion begins January 30, 2017.