#BookBeginnings Downfall by J.A. Jance

Let’s look at the first paragraph of J. A. Jance’s Downfall  for Book Beginnings on Fridays, hosted at Rose City Reader.


Downfall* by J.A. Jance

(*Affiliate link)


Cochise County Sheriff Joanna Brady has recently lost her mother and stepfather. Now she must investigate the death of two women at a local landmark, while at the same time running for re-election for her job.

First Paragraph of Prologue:

Sheriff Joanna Brady pulled into the parking place in front of Higgins Funeral Chapel, put her Buick Enclave in park, and then sat staring at the storefront before her, only vaguely aware of her surroundings. Lowering clouds blanketed the Mule Mountains in southeastern Arizona. It was the last day of August. The summer monsoons had arrived early and stayed on, leaving the desert grassland valleys of Cochise County lush and green.


Discussion:  As we can see, Jance describes the weather in the first paragraph, along with introducing the main character and setting. In his famous essay for writers, Elmore Leonard says the first rule of writing  is never to open a book with the weather. Is there a bigger cliche than, “It was a dark and stormy night…”?

Of course rules are meant to be broken, and in this case the weather helps define the setting. In Arizona the summer monsoon marks a season of humidity and violent thunderstorms. They are unique to that time and place.

As a reader, what do you think of books that start with a description of the weather?

Do you read on, skip it, or put the book down?




Recent post about J.A. Jance


  1. Karen

    I’m always interested in weather, so I’d keep reading. 🙂

    I’ll have to hunt up this book and give it a try. I love reading stories set in familiar locations.

    • Roberta


      This is a series. I recommend you start with the first one, Desert Heat.

  2. Karen @ The Well-Read Pirate Queen

    As much as I love Elmore (and cried like a baby when he passed), sometimes weather is a great way to set things up. Sounds like this may be one of those times!

    • Roberta

      It does seem like most of his “rules” are meant to be guidelines instead.

  3. Laurel-Rain Snow

    I agree that “weather talk” helps to define the setting…and sometimes the mood of the characters. Thanks for sharing…and for visiting my blog.

  4. Sandra Nachlinger

    I agree that rules are made to be broken. As a reader (and writer) I like to know the book’s setting right away, and describing the weather in the scene can add to the mood and create tension. Just don’t go on and on and on about it! Downfall sounds like a book I’d enjoy.
    My Friday post features BEYOND THE ASHES.

    • Roberta

      I think Jance uses it to add tension, too. Lightning starts flashing soon afterwards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

© 2024 It's A Mystery Blog

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑